Judge Rinder ‘litigant’ claims to have faked legal row to secure £5,000 ITV payout

Avatar photo

By Thomas Connelly on

Sam Horner took pal to TV courtroom after discovering show coughs up damages, according to report

Sam Horner and Paul Brewster (Credit: ITV)

It’s been revealed two friends apparently concocted a fake legal claim to trick ITV’s Judge Rinder into coughing up £5,000 in damages. A spokeswoman for ITV has told Legal Cheek the channel may now be approaching the police over the matter.

Sam Horner appeared on the daytime programme to make a claim relating to a £6,100 office refurbishment against his pal, Paul Brewster. Horner demanded damages and purportedly “created a fake paper trail of invoices and final demands”, according to The Sun.

Interestingly, the report suggests that Leeds plasterer Horner invented the legal quarrel after discovering “producers [at] ITV pay out the cash — not the defendants.”

The newspaper further claims to have seen text messages between the duo arranging the ploy, which hit TV screens earlier this month. Horner, who was eventually awarded £5,000, said: “It was an Oscar-winning performance from start to finish. By the end Judge Rinder was utterly convinced. Me and Paul went on the piss to celebrate afterwards and have split the £5,000.”

ITV doesn’t seem to share Horner’s enthusiasm. A spokeswoman for the TV channel told Legal Cheek:

If they have defrauded us we will take this up with police.

However, Horner doesn’t appear too concerned about any potential legal ramifications for his actions. He said: “I haven’t done anything wrong. I was paid for entertainment and that’s exactly what I gave them. I was paid to act.”

Ruling in the case at the time, Judge Rinder — who is actually 2 Hare Court criminal barrister Robert Rinder — said:

It’s difficult to find a case where the applicant was more entitled to the full sum.

UPDATE: 11:55pm – Tuesday 26 September

Rinder has now responded to our story:

For all the latest commercial awareness info, and advance notification of Legal Cheek’s careers events, sign up to the Legal Cheek Hub.