News

Number of lawyers in Justice Committee drops by almost a third as new members revealed

By on
15

Now there’s only one solicitor

Portcullis House, Westminster, London

The new faces of the Justice Committee have been revealed, and 29% less of them are lawyers than previously.

At the end of May 2017 when parliament was dissolved, seven of the 11 Committee members (64%) were lawyers, i.e. had practised. One other MP had graduated in law and been a magistrate, so if you factor her in too then 73% were lawyers.

Now, however, only five members have actually practised law, which is 45%. One more has a law degree, so including her gives you a lawyer percentage of 54%. Using the former figure of solicitors or barristers, there are now two less lawyers on the Committee than there were this spring, equalling a drop of 29%.

Still at the Committee’s helm is ex-criminal barrister Bob Neill MP, who on these changes in lawyer numbers told us:

The numbers of people on [the Committee] who happen to be lawyers comes and goes, nothing significant in it, and of course we also deal with prisons, probation, etc.

It’s perhaps also worth noting that, in an interview with Legal Cheek earlier this year, former 2 Bedford Row tenant Neill lambasted the ferocity of legal aid cuts. He said: “The government gets the sense this just isn’t sustainable. We have taken out as much as we can, we cannot take out anymore.” The Committee will have an important role to play in the upcoming review on these cuts.

Other legally minded MPs to follow Neill onto the newly announced Committee are fellow barristers Alex Chalk and Victoria Prentis. Employment law barrister Ellie Reeves and housing solicitor Bambos Charalambous round off the quintet, and there’s Birkbeck, University of London graduate Kemi Badenoch too.

Prior to yesterday’s announcement, the Committee had enjoyed a strong solicitor input from MPs Keith Vaz, Alberto Costa, Richard Arkless and Jo Stevens (over one third of the select committee). Now, it’s just under one tenth. Kate Green, an Edinburgh University law graduate and former magistrate with over 15 years experience, has also not made the new Justice Committee cut.

As an interesting non-lawyer aside, political pundits may be interested to trace the Committee’s new party make-up. There are now less Tories than there were back in May (six versus five), meaning the scale is tipped towards non-Conservatives than Conservatives overall. Scotland has had a representative in both committees, but there’s no one from the Liberal Democrats, for example.

Justice Committee members as of May 2017

Name Lawyer? Party
Bob Neill Yes, barrister Conservative
Richard Arkless Yes, solicitor SNP
Alex Chalk Yes, barrister Conservative
Alberto Costa Yes, solicitor Conservative
Philip Davies No, marketer Conservative
Kate Green No, but she is a law graduate and magistrate Labour
David Hanson No, charity worker Labour
John Howell No, tax adviser Conservative
Victoria Prentis Yes, barrister Conservative
Jo Stevens Yes, solicitor Labour
Keith Vaz Yes, solicitor Labour

Justice Committee members now

Name Lawyer? Party
Bob Neill Yes, barrister Conservative
Kemi Badenoch No, but she is a law graduate Conservative
Ruth Cadbury No, councillor Labour
Alex Chalk Yes, barrister Conservative
Bambos Charalambous Yes, solicitor Labour
David Hanson No, charity worker Labour
John Howell No, tax adviser Conservative
Gavin Newlands No, business analyst SNP
Laura Pidcock No, mental health support worker Labour
Victoria Prentis Yes, barrister Conservative
Ellie Reeves Yes, barrister Labour

For all the latest commercial awareness info, and advance notification of Legal Cheek’s careers events, sign up to the Legal Cheek Hub.

15 Comments

Anonymous

Victoria Prentis – I shamefully misread that name. Tee hee hee.

(2)(0)

Anonymous

Fewer Katie, not less.

(11)(0)

Anonymous

The countable subject (the number of lawyers) is muddled as a percentage so I can see where her poor little cotton socks got confused.

(1)(0)

Anonymous

Ellie Reeves didn’t really practice at the Bar. After qualification she worked in solicitors firms the whole time.

(0)(0)

Anonymous

Given that there no UKIP MPs it is not surprising that there are no UKIP members on the committee.

(3)(0)

Anonymous

Pretty poor journalism on show here.

(0)(0)

Anonymous

Carswell?

(0)(0)

Anonymous

Left UKIP before the election

(0)(0)

Anonymous

And indeed is no longer an MP.

(0)(0)

Anonymous

I like how you showed your working for the percentages calculation. You know full well we wouldn’t trust you with numbers without providing the justification.

(0)(0)

Anonymous

David Hanson may not have been a lawyer, but he was Minister of State for Justice for two years (2007-9) and at the Home Office for a further year (2009-10).

(0)(0)

Not Amused

Isn’t it slightly more concerning that the LC is not a lawyer and that the AG is an idiot?

The fact that the committee is also full of D listers is hardly number 1 priority …

(0)(0)

Anonymous

One other MP had graduated in law and been a magistrate, so if you factor her in too then 73% were lawyers.

No Katie, just No. You cannot call yourself a lawyer because you did three years study and perform a role that is regularly fulfilled by lay people with as little as 16 hours training.

(0)(0)

Anonymous

Kemi Badenoch

Future Prime Minister

You heard it here first

(0)(0)

Not Amused

I agree she is destined for more and greater things. Her maiden was brilliant.

(0)(0)

Comments are closed.