Law students bag first win for university pro bono projects as murder conviction is overturned

Avatar photo

By Judge John Hack on

High judicial praise for Cardiff’s Innocence Project in a case that also sees a “hot” barrister shoot back into the limelight


Media references to lawyers tend to swing between “fat cats” and “legal aid cheats”, so it is encouraging to find widespread mainstream coverage today of a stunning victory for Cardiff University law students in overturning a long-standing miscarriage of justice.

The Court of Appeal yesterday overturned Dwaine George’s murder conviction of a dozen years ago, a result owed in large part to the hard graft of students and academics at Cardiff Law School’s Innocence Project.

George (pictured below) was convicted of murder when he was 18 and served 12 years in prison. When the Criminal Cases Review Commission initially referred his case to the Appeal Court, it praised the students’ work, saying the Innocence Project had “made a very significant contribution to the case”.


The Cardiff University scheme was launched eight years ago and was one of the first three innocence projects in the UK. It involves law students — under the supervision of specialist practising lawyers — investigating cases of long-term prisoners that maintain their innocence of serious crimes for which they have been convicted.

George’s case was the first success for any UK university innocence project.

Some 30 present and past students joined law school academics Julie Price and Dennis Eady — who jointly run the Cardiff project — yesterday at London’s Royal Courts of to hear the ruling.


The judgment — handed down by Appeal Court chairman Sir Brian Leveson — said:

“In addition to expressing our gratitude to the Criminal Cases Review Commission, we pay tribute to the work of the Innocence Project and Pro Bono Unit at Cardiff Law School, which took up the appellant’s case and pursued it so diligently.”

Caitlin Gallagher, who worked on the case as a student and on the appeal as a trainee solicitor, commented:

“Dwaine inspired the team at Cardiff Law School to join his long journey to clear his name through a scheme that doesn’t just educate, but enthuses and assists students to pursue a career in criminal law.”

Professor Price added:

“For Cardiff Law School Innocence Project, and other university projects working on alleged wrongful conviction cases, this is a significant day. It demonstrates that universities are about more than research, and can show public impact from innovative teaching and learning.”

She went on to describe the result has a “collaborative effort” and pointed to significant problems around the criminal appeals process.

“Just look at how long it’s taken with this case, and this is the first of its kind,” said Price. “There are many meritorious cases that will not be overturned as the law currently stands.”

She claimed that:

“Miscarriages of justice attract little political and public interest, and with the attack on legal aid, the problem is going to get worse. University projects are a sticking plaster only and cannot replace a properly funded legal aid system.”

Speaking after the ruling, George also heaped praise on the students. Today I have got the result I wanted,” he said.

“I have lost a lot of my life that I can’t get back, but I just want to get on with my life now. I hope the Cardiff Innocence Project will get all the recognition it deserves for this. I want to thank all those who helped me — the students and staff at Cardiff, my solicitor David McCorkle, James Wood QC and Tunde Okewale from Doughty Street Chambers”.

Indeed, Okewale’s involvement gave the story an added media boost. Several weeks ago, style bible GQ named the seven-year-call junior as one of the coolest chaps in Britain. He also came near the top of this year’s Hottie Barrister List.


Dwaine George