It’s ‘foolish’ to blame the solicitor, says Afghan-born barrister stripped of case after client requested ‘white male’

Avatar photo

By Thomas Connelly on

Rehana Popal hit headlines last year after tweeting about incident

Rehana Popal

The Afghan-born barrister who was asked to return a case because her client wanted to be represented by “a white male” has said it would have been “foolish and simplistic” to blame the solicitor involved.

Writing in Counsel Magazine, Rehana Popal, a junior barrister at London’s 10 King’s Bench Walk, said she had received “overwhelming” levels of support from fellow lawyers since tweeting about the incident last November.

Despite being urged to report the solicitor to the regulator at the time, Popal said that this “would not address the root cause of the problem, nor make a material difference to the client’s instructions.” Popal, who came to the UK as a child refugee from Afghanistan, explained:

“If I made my solicitor the ‘scapegoat’, they may no longer have been so honest with me; and any future reasons for disinstructing may just have been packaged in a different way.”

Popal said it was made clear to her by her instructing solicitor that the client believed that the judge would be more persuaded by a white male advocate — someone the client “considered to look like the judge”. Stressing that the client’s perception of the justice system is the real problem and that reporting the solicitor wasn’t going to change that, the immigration and civil law specialist continued:

“We cannot escape the fact that the judiciary is overwhelmingly male and Caucasian. Great efforts have been made in recent years to diversify the judiciary and encourage applications to join the bench by those under represented. The fruit of these efforts, at the most senior end, will not be seen for years to come.”

Speaking to Legal Cheek back in November, Popal said the incident reminded her again of the “importance of promoting diversity at all levels of the legal system”. She added: “As much as I disagree with how the solicitor handled this, I appreciate the honesty because it has led to this conversation. We can only go forward from here.”

At the time, the Law Society’s president, Christina Blacklaws, warned that solicitors must not discriminate unlawfully against anyone on the grounds of any protected characteristic, while a spokesperson for the Solicitors Regulation Authority (SRA) stressed that it takes all “allegations of potential discrimination seriously”.

The 2019 Legal Cheek Chambers Most List

Related Stories

Afghan-born junior barrister asked to return case after client requested ‘a white male’

'This was an unexpected and upsetting event', says Rehana Popal

Nov 8 2018 11:06am

Britain’s first black female High Court judge opens up about racism at the bar

Clerks would Tippex out her name on briefs and write in the name of male pupil they wanted to be the tenant

Mar 30 2016 1:11pm

Top black judge who said ‘racism is alive and well’ among the judiciary is reprimanded over ‘inappropriate’ comments

Peter Herbert gave a public speech following Tower Hamlets electoral fraud scandal

Apr 7 2017 11:29am