JLD welcomes decision not to strike off struggling junior lawyer

By on

Susan Orton binned documents ‘in a moment of sheer panic’

The Junior Lawyers Division (JLD) has welcomed the decision not to strike off a young solicitor for acting dishonestly after a tribunal found that her mental ill-health represented exceptional circumstances which warranted a suspension instead.

The Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal (SDT) heard how Susan Orton, who had been qualified for two years at the time, removed two copies of a hearing notification from a file in 2018 after she realised she had missed a planned preliminary hearing at the Employment Tribunal.

“In a moment of sheer panic”, the junior lawyer then placed the docs in two of the office’s locked confidential waste bins, The Law Society Gazette reports. Orton, who worked at Cheltenham law firm BPE Solicitors, was spotted by a secretary who subsequently reported her.

The tribunal heard that she had suffered panic attacks since a child and was diagnosed with a mental health condition following the incident that contributed to her response.

The SDT cleared Orton of dishonesty over the binning of the notifications, but found she acted dishonestly when she denied having seen them both in an email to the Employment Tribunal and in a meeting with her superiors. She was suspended for two and a half years, although this was reduced to six months after the tribunal factored in the time she had already spent out of work.

The 2021 Legal Cheek Firms Most List

Welcoming the ruling, the JLD said that some high-profile regulator decisions to prosecute junior lawyers in recent years had “failed to give sufficient recognition to the substantial impact of mental health issues on professionals”. The group said it was “concerned particularly regarding junior lawyers who are new to the specific pressures of the legal industry, and the harsh finality of decisions to strike off”.

It continued:

“The JLD hopes the SDT continues to be as conscious of the significant impact of such issues in future determinations, and that the SRA takes note of the Orton outcome when considering whether to prosecute other junior lawyers in similar circumstances in the future.”

The group went on to cite its own junior lawyer wellbeing survey which found that almost half (48%) of the 1,803 respondents had experienced problems with their mental health in the previous month — a proportion significantly higher than the general population.

Feeling stressed? You can contact LawCare by calling 0800 279 6888 in the UK.



The quality of mercy is not strained.
It droppeth as the gentle rain from heaven
Upon the place beneath. It is twice blest:
It blesseth him that gives and him that takes.
‘Tis mightiest in the mightiest; it becomes
The thronèd monarch better than his crown.



Still, most of the time the SDT just kicks out the mentally ill with no mercy at all.


Jacqueline Doyle

People make many mistakes in life especially those with stressful and challenging jobs. It is often what makes a good lawyer, always learning as we go though our career. The is why we say we “practice” the law. We will never know everything or get everything right first time. I’m sure the girl will never miss a court date in future. I’m not sure I could say that about myself and I’ve been practicing law for 30 years and I’m a judge on Tribunals ??‍?


Martin Routh

Again, this constant error about what these cases are about. The “mistake” for which the solicitor was disciplined was not missing a court date; it was throwing notices of hearing in the bin. Firmly disagree that “mistakes” of this order “often…make a good lawyer”.

I am pleased to say that when it comes to throwing away notices of hearing in an attempt to mislead, yes I *have* always got it right first time, as I would hope and believe have most practitioners.

And we don’t “practice” the law; we “practise” the law.


Comments are closed.

Related Stories