News

Scotland can’t vote on independence without UK parliament’s permission, rules Supreme Court

By on
3

Unanimous decision

The UK’s top court has found that the Scottish parliament does not have the power to legislate for a referendum on Scottish independence.

The issue arose after the Scottish Independence Reference Bill was drafted by the Scottish National Party which is the largest political party in Scotland. The bill makes provision for a referendum on the question, “Should Scotland be an independent country?”.

The Supreme Court heard submissions on the 11 and 12 October with the case turning on whether the power to legislate for a referendum had been devolved by the UK Parliament or reserved under the Scotland Act 1998.

Having initially stated at the start of the hearing that it was “likely to be some months” before a judgment was delivered, the five-strong panel of Supreme Court justices (Lord Reed, Lord Lloyd-Jones, Lord Sales, Lord Stephens, Lady Rose) handed down their ruling in just six weeks.

The court explained that a provision will relate to a reserved matter if it has something more than a loose or consequential connection with the matters listed under section 29(2)(b) Scotland Act 1998.

The 2023 Legal Cheek Firms Most List

In a unanimous judgment, it found that “it is plain that a Bill which makes provision for a referendum on independence — on ending the Union — has more than a loose or consequential connection with the Union of Scotland and England.”

Further submissions based on the right to self–determination in international law and the principle of legality made by the SNP were also rejected by the Supreme Court. You can read the full judgment here.

This means that the provision of ‘indyref2’ will have to go through Westminster unless the definition of reserved matters is modified.

First Minister of Scotland and leader of the SNP said she respected the Supreme Court’s ruling, adding:

“A law that doesn’t allow Scotland to choose our own future without Westminster consent exposes as myth any notion of the UK as a voluntary partnership & makes case for Indy. Scottish democracy will not be denied. Today’s ruling blocks one route to Scotland’s voice being heard on independence — but in a democracy our voice cannot and will not be silenced.”

A full statement from the First Minister is expected later this morning.

For all the latest commercial awareness info, news and careers advice:

Sign up to the Legal Cheek Newsletter

3 Comments

Joris Bohnson

They voted 8 years ago, they lost. Your offshore oil is ours forever!

Get over it and God Save The King.

Anonymous

Here here chaps !

Jock McTavish LLP

Aye we have a wee problem here…

When there’s a Tory UK government, its always imposed upon the Scots by the English because there’s never been a majority of Tory MPs in Scotland since the 50s…

But when there’s a Labour UK government, they only ever have a majority because of Scottish Labour MPs.

So no one is ever happy and it’s always the fault of the “other”, however you look at it.

But here’s the rub- when it comes to the issue of “self determination”, this one isn’t like colonies going independent.

Scotland isn’t and never has been an English colony.

The Scottish monarchy took the English throne when Elizabeth I died without heirs.

And all that Jacobite rebellion stuff that is portrayed as a Scotland v England thing is rubbish too- it was about Catholic and Protestant claims to the throne which both originated from the Stuart (ie Scottish) line!

Wee Nicki the Fish doesn’t get any of that.

Join the conversation

Related Stories