Category Archives: Judges

Judicial ‘Pepsi Challenge’ fails as law students are unable to identify judges’ gender from their anonymised rulings

By |

Pepsi-challengeDurham University law students' attempt to tell the gender of a judge on the basis of their judgment alone has yielded a success rate of just 46%.

The experiment — a legal version, if you will, of the famous Pepsi Challenge (a blind Pepsi v Coke taste test) — was conducted following prompting by Supreme Court President Lord Neuberger amid controversy at the lack of female judges...

Continue reading

‘I heard a voice whisper: “What a ghastly portrait of insufferable arrogance” – and I realised he meant me’

By |

This is my 36th year at the Bar and things have changed a hell of a lot for the better. Although if Grayling's wicked proposals to hand over our justice system to the corporate blood suckers come to pass, the independent criminal Bar will be summarily executed without trial and without mitigation within two years, writes barrister and former Tory MP Jerry Hayes in the latest post in the 'If I knew then what I know now' series.

The truth is that, apart from the minor irritation that the government doesn't want to pay us and that we are all hocked up to the eyeballs, being a criminal barrister is the best job in the world. I can't think of any more enjoyable way of spending a day than knocking nine bells out of a less than truthful witness, making a jury laugh or cry, and then popping into El Vinos for a few vats of claret...

Continue reading

Judge threatens to hold ‘very rude’ solicitor in contempt of court after extraordinary bust-up

By |

The atmosphere in Bristol Magistrates' court number three became rather heated last week as District Judge Simon Cooper and solicitor Peter Balchin locked horns in dramatic fashion. It got so bad at one point that Cooper asked for the names of every other lawyer in the courtroom to be recorded by the usher in case they'd need to be called as witnesses at a future hearing...

fight

Continue reading

10 of the best Lord Justice Ward lines

By |

justice_wardLast month, retiring Court of Appeal judge Sir Alan Ward (pictured) used his penultimate judgment to deliver a wistful nautical-themed allegory about departing the Royal Courts of Justice.

It wasn't the first time that he'd made lawyers smile. Here are ten of his best lines...

'Warring bankers'

boring-meme

"This case involves a number of – and here I must not fall into Dr Spooner’s error – warring bankers." [Inforrm]

Continue reading