News

Ministers don’t understand why they can’t just break the law, civil servants claim

By on
9

Officials say certain politicians just don’t get that the rule of law is a thing

Some government ministers need to have it carefully explained to them why they can’t deliberately break the law, a new report claims.

Civil servants told researchers that certain politicians have no idea what the big deal is about cracking on with their plans in face of warnings that it would be illegal.

The Institute for Government spoke to a range of Westminister insiders for a report on legal advice in government. Among the findings was that politicians’ appetite for legal risk varies a fair bit, from those who “take what lawyers say as gospel” to those who have no clue that the rule of law is a thing at all.

Quoting a former official, the report says that: “[T]he most difficult were those who ‘totally refused to accept the fundamentals on which officials and lawyers were giving advice’, leading to the problem of finding the right language to explain to them why they could not break the law.”

The Johnson government has been embroiled in several rows over its attitude to legal constraints. Last September, chief civil service lawyer Jonathan Jones QC and Scottish law officer Lord Keen QC dramatically quit in protest at the administration’s plans to deliberately breach international law.

The latest comments from across Legal Cheek

More recently, Justice Secretary Robert Buckland has also been accused of distorting the findings of an independent Faulks report on judicial review. Respected silk David Anderson, a former national security watchdog, pointed out that “the minister’s foreword to the consultation claims that the panel identified a growing tendency for the courts to review the merits of decisions, and to replace the reasoning of decision-makers with their own. But the report contains no such conclusion”.

The government is now pressing ahead with restrictions to judicial review, despite the Faulks report giving little backing for radical changes. A consultation on its proposals closes on 29 April.

The Institute for Government argues that judicial review would cause less frustration “if ministers and civil servants better understood what legal advice is for and how to use it”.

Getting it into ministers’ heads that breaking the law is actually a problem could be a good place to start.

Sign up to the Legal Cheek Newsletter

9 Comments

Martin

This will continue to be a problem as long as governments continue to have ministers who are totally fucking thick.

(38)(2)

Blind leading the blind

Then stop willingly voting for them every election just because it will save you a few quid on your tax bill.

(10)(3)

Anon

A rampant sense of entitlement and the knowledge that their new beloved Red Wall base think the law and civil service are the problem does not help. The country has no effective opposition for the rational and educated to vote for either.

(22)(1)

A

At least Boris has responded to these disclosures. By ordering an inquiry into the whistle-blower, sorry, leak. Says it all right there. A witch hunt around those flagging corruption risks in the middle of a growing corruption scandal.

(3)(4)

BD

Nail on Head. 😉

(0)(1)

Touker

The Thick of It is still extremely accurate in its portrayal of the government, the Opposition and the Civil Service

(11)(0)

wait for it

I remember reading that Armando Ianucci regrets making the series because too many SpAds and MPs nowadays model themselves on people in the show…which was meant to be a satire and mockery of their jobs and failure to do them properly…

(3)(0)

Barry

I like how only the anti government posts are getting through… typical of LC’s bias. This is my third attempt at commenting criticizing the promotion of unsubstantiated claims as if they were fact.

(2)(10)

Bozza J

Err…umumumum…PHWOAR!….Yes… we….can break the law….err…but but… only! Yes…only… PHWOAR! Err… umumumumum… in very…specific!… andand limited! Er… circumstances!

(3)(1)

Comments are closed.

Related Stories