‘Can I secure a training contract with a 2:2 from Cambridge and mitigating circumstances?’

Avatar photo

By Legal Cheek on

10

Targeting Magic and Silver Circle firms


In our latest Career Conundrum, an aspiring lawyer wants to know whether their 2:2 from Cambridge — with mitigating circumstances — is enough to help them secure a training contract at a top City law firm.

“Hi Legal Cheek. I am in the process of applying for Vacation Schemes and want to ask your readers what they think my chances are of securing a training contract at a Magic Circle or Silver Circle law firm in London. I studied a non-law degree at Cambridge and achieved a 2:2. During my first year and a half, I experienced serious health issues that affected my performance. Do law firms genuinely take mitigating circumstances into account, or am I basically screwed?”

NEW: The 2026 Legal Cheek Firms Most List

10 Comments

Stephen

Is it possible to get a TC? It will be difficult but possible.

Is it possible to get a MC or SC TC? Close to impossible.

MC firms get about 5,000 applicants each year and almost all of them will have stellar academics and extracurriculars. Only about 1% of them will get it, so if you don’t even have a 2:1 when 99% of applicants will, don’t even bother, irrespective of health issues.

However, I think people forget that is a huge world of law firms outside of the MC/SC that will offer great opportunities and training. It’s not the be-all-and-end-all. I find the fixation with it from a lot of students tiresome.

Andy

This – agreed. Not impossible, but very very difficult. Unless you can get in front of the HR / recruitment team to explain the extenuating circumstances, a 2:2 will get filtered out by magic circle firms.

Put in an application to one sure, but consider National and some Regional firms as they can provide great opportunities / work. If you can secure a TC and qualify, you can then apply to a magic circle firm if it remains of interest.

fed up of wokeism

be realistic.

Seen this question a million times

You won’t get anywhere with those firms in the current market, no. Forget it. 2.2 is really bad nowadays, regardless of circs.

Emma

Back in the day when you didn’t have HR lefties running grad rec and the partners knew that a 2:2 was worth more than a First from a non-Russell group you would have had a chance. If you have any DEI characteristics definitely play them up and concoct the biggest sob story you can. Even say you’re bisexual if you’re straight – no-one can say you’re not.

7PQEr

The harsh but realistic answer is your chances are low. Even though you went to Cambridge, the market is perpetually competitive and a 2:2 rightfully puts you towards the back of the queue compared to grads from other elite unis who got 1sts and 2:1s (especially those who have gotten some legal work experience). That being said, you should consider being more open minded and applying to firms outside of the MC/SC bubble

Friendly advisor

This depends on the law firm specifically. For example, Slaughters are unlikely to take anyone with a 2:2, but other firms might take a different approach. I would say that your other grades might make a difference (pre-degree) and the specifics of the mitigating circumstances. It’s definitely not the end of the road, but be intentional with where you apply so you are not wasting time and energy into firms who won’t look at your application. I would contact graduate recruitment before applying with your specific circumstances so that you can gauge the likelihood of them taking your application seriously.

Reality check

The issue here is that the circumstances only impacted the first 18 months of the degree and the final 18 months are likely to have been weighted more heavily for the final grade.

Going be the limited information in this situation, it sounds like the individual probably didn’t do well in their final year either when the circumstances weren’t impacting their studies.

Quack Doctor

You’re not screwed.

Some firms will be better than others. I would expect – but don’t actually know – that magic circle firms will generally mind a bit more as they place more emphasis on academics full stop.

However, many silver circle firms will be much less fussed and will progress your application, at which point grades don’t really matter anyway.

A few things I would say:

1) The rest of your CV will need to be decent. This sort of goes without saying, but will be especially important here.

2) It’s helpful if you can point to contrast between your normal performance and health-impacted performance. Draw attention to a good before-during-after type narrative if you have one (which I assume you must).

3) Bill having pushed through and still achieved what you have as a serious challenge that you’re proud to have been able to overcome.

4) Hammer home in the application that the health issue chapter is closed (this is fact specific and may or may not be self-evident). You shouldn’t need to do this really, but what firms actually care about is that you will be able to perform.

5) If you’re worried or if you’re laser focused on going to a top top firm, consider a masters (if circumstances allow) and devote yourself to absolutely smashing it. That would then leave you in a position where you don’t need to convince people (no matter how subtlety the question is posed) that you’re a good egg who fell on hard times through no fault of your own. Having got into Cambridge doesn’t hurt there either, tbh.

Good luck. Speaking with experience, you’ll be fine.

Passingby@law

I got a 2.2 and I’m currently working in a big us law firm! I did go to a Russell group uni and I got mitigating circumstances myself. Honestly, I’d suggest really pushing yourself to get a lot of work experience. Before securing my tc, I worked in most mc and 2 us law firms to get the attention away from my grades. As long as you can show you can showcase your skills and knowledge in the legal field, most firms really don’t care apart from S&M 😅.

Join the conversation

Related Stories