Advice needed
In our latest career conundrum submission, a future trainee who has already accepted a TC is wondering whether they can jump ship for a Magic Circle offer — and what consequences they might face.
“Hi there, I accepted a TC offer because I applied to a number of firms in the past year, but struggled to secure even a vac scheme. My TC will start in 2028 and I sit the SQE in 2027. I have since graduated and received a 1st Class degree from a top uni. I’ve now also received a TC offer from a Magic Circle firm. Can I renege on my accepted TC offer to take one from the Magic Circle firm without consequences or penalties? Pls advise.”
On the hunt for a training contract this Autumn? Sign up to The Legal Cheek September Virtual Law Fair, taking place on Wednesday 2 September, 2-5pm. Nearly 60 top law firms will be attending and you will have the chance to chat to lawyers, trainees and graduate recruitment to hear about the work they do and what they’re looking for in new trainees.
Of course you can, however, the conversation with your current firm will be awkward, but they should understand that candidates do get better offers and shouldn’t give you a hard time. I assume you haven’t received any monies from your current firm either, so there shouldn’t be any penalties, or any clawback matters to worry about.
Lesson #1 as your start your career: put yourself before any firm. Do what is best for you.
I’m going to leave to one side the morals and legality of reneging on Firm A: the first is for your conscience and the second unlikely to be a serious concern.
So then the clear answer. If you aspire as a qualified lawyer to work in Firm A, take that TC; if you aspire to work in Firm MC, take that TC.
The best way to get a job in any firm as a qualified lawyer is to have done a TC in it. That’s statistically true and is common sense. So you simply have to ask yourself do you want a qualified position in Firm A or Firm MC. The stuff about quality of training might be true but given we don’t know about Firm A, we can’t comment.
Technically you can. It’s all a question of how you put your case across and the reasons you give. You haven’t started your TC OR your SQE training yet. From the firm’s perspective, there’s no investment lost.
Whatever you do, refrain from telling bare-faced lies or providing excessive amounts of detail. Keep your reason short, credible and to the point. Don’t tell the sort of lie that could cause problems for you down the line. Contact the grad rec team ASAP and possibly schedule a meeting to discuss that you are unable to move forward with your TC. In most cases, they are understanding and flexible.
I’ve heard of people starting the SQE course and then deciding to abandon their TC upon realising how challenging the process is. They weren’t penalised by the firms in question. I’d like to think your circumstances are more favourable.
On a final note, ask yourself why you are reneging on your accepted offer. If it’s simply because you’ve now received a magic circle TC offer, then think long, hard and deep about the benefits/trade-offs. Magic circle retention rates (except Links and perhaps Slaughters) have been atrocious for the past few years. So ultimately you might be trading long-term stability for short-term prestige.
A vague question, limited context and “pls advise”, this reads more like an email from a PE sponsor at 23:54 on a Sunday than a career query.
In all seriousness, in practice, plenty of people have reneged in the past without consequence (and it is broadly not in firms’ interests to come down hard on those who do), but you should probably read the terms of the offer carefully to check if there are specific prohibitions on applying to other firms after acceptance etc. If the enrollment process for the relevant SQE course has already started, the firm may also be less inclined to let it slide.
Yes, take the money.
Yes.
You’re not going to hurt the firm’s feelings. To put it bluntly, right now you are just a number out of a pool of future trainees.
Don’t give up opportunities that could really benefit your life for the sake of a firm that will go on just fine without you.
They will probably have your spot replaced within a week.