Should legal crowdfunding be regulated?

Avatar photo

By CJ McKinney on

Lawyers — including some of those doing the crowdfunding — worry about lack of controls

As the scale of legal crowdfunding grows, so have calls for regulation.

Online platforms increasingly allow people and organisations to raise the money they need to go to court via small donations, but critics worry about the lack of controls on how donors’ money is spent.

The latest intervention comes from the anonymous but respected legal commentator Spinning Hugo, who says that crowdfunding should only be allowed for specific cases, with general fundraising for worthy causes left to properly regulated charities.

The blogger was responding to the Legal Defence Fund for Transgender Lives, set up by the Good Law Project. It has raised over £134,000 in the past few months to “tackle the tide of transphobia — and its legal consequences”.

Unlike previous legal crowdfunding efforts, the money is not being raised for any one specific case, although part of it is being used to help challenge a High Court ruling on whether children can consent to taking puberty-blocking drugs.

In a series of tweets, Spinning Hugo argued that “there doesn’t appear to be a trust for anyone, or any control that the donors can exercise over the funds’ subsequent use… crowdfunding for litigation to protect, say, LGBQT rights is much better done by charities, who are necessarily regulated”.

They added: “we need to limit crowdfunding to that for specific cases”.

Barrister Steven Barrett agrees, predicting that “large pools of money taken from the public and put in to the hands of a few for an unspecified purpose seldom remain unregulated for long”.

Last year the Good Law Project raised £374,000 in case-specific donations but also £222,000 in “membership income and general donations”, according to company accounts.

The organisation has made extensive use of the CrowdJustice platform. Crowdfunders in the name of the Good Law Project or its director, Jolyon Maugham QC, have raised over £2 million since 2017.

When an individual is using CrowdJustice to fundraise for their own case, the money raised goes directly to the person’s solicitor or legal representative. But when the fundraising is by “an organisation, charity or NGO” or for a “general legal project”, the CrowdJustice terms of use allow the organiser to collect the money directly.

Barbara Rich of 5 Stone Buildings points out that a private company raising money in this way lacks “the definition of objects, legal duties and liabilities of trustees, or supervisory regime of a formal, registered charitable trust”.

The Good Law Project is a private company limited by guarantee, rather than a charity or community interest company, although its articles of association state that it is not for profit. The company did not respond to a request for comment, but Maugham has previously called for “careful regulatory intervention” on crowdfunding. He has also criticised “crowdfunding cases where people are raising for only very vaguely specified pieces of legal work”.

Lawyers involved in crowdfunding are bound by their usual professional duties but there is no regulation of crowdfunding specifically. In a 2019 paper, the academic Joe Tomlinson called for legal regulators to get involved, saying that “the crowdfunding model is open to use by a wide variety of actors and therefore potentially abuse of various kinds by both the malevolent or misguided”.

Marcus Ball, who devoted several years of his life to a crowdfunded prosecution of Boris Johnson, has revealed that losing the case left him £200,000 in debt despite raising over £500,000 in crowdfunding.

Another crowdfunder exploring the private prosecution of Dominic Cummings raised over £40,000 last year. Having received legal advice that a private prosecution was not possible, the page seems to have gone quiet. The last update, in August 2020, said that “we are currently collating and formulating the advice around the private prosecution of Dominic Cummings. We anticipate this will be concluded by the end of September”.

The solicitor involved, Tasnime Akunjee, told Legal Cheek in November “I am hoping to get the report to [the organiser] in the next week or two” but did not respond to our latest request for comment.

Sign up to the Legal Cheek Newsletter

Related Stories

Top blogging barrister warns Birkbeck law grad that her crowdfunded Dominic Cummings prosecution is doomed

Revised legal advice to Mahsa Taliefar is expected to row back on prospects of success

Jul 2 2020 2:48pm
careers SQE Hub

‘My SQE journey as a non-law student with dyslexia’

ULaw student Freya Patten shares her experience of the SQE and her transition from a science grad to future lawyer

20 hours ago

City law ‘drinking culture’ poses major challenge for aspiring Muslim lawyers

New report spotlights challenges facing Bangladeshi and Pakistani applicants

20 hours ago
17
news SQE Hub

‘Enormous opportunity missed’: Law school chief hits out at ethnicity attainment gap report 

City Law School's James Catchpole questions exclusion of SQE students in long-awaited research

20 hours ago
1

Half of lawyers want self-regulation when it comes to AI

New report highlights adoption concerns within the profession

2 days ago
news SQE Hub

Why it’s not too late to save the SQE

Legal education godfather Professor Nigel Savage has a plan

2 days ago
15
careers SQE Hub

Why high quality mock exams are the key to SQE success

QLTS explains how it’s supporting students and challenging the traditional providers

3 days ago

Only half the public think lawyers have positive impact on society

Negative stereotypes and press coverage partly to blame

3 days ago
12

Monday morning round-up

The top legal affairs news stories from this morning and the weekend

3 days ago

‘Lord Harley’ scoops two legal awards

Gongs come despite 2016 strike-off

6 days ago
6

Best of the blogs

Weekly round-up of the top legal blogosphere posts

6 days ago

BSB greenlights restart of Hertfordshire Uni bar course

Suspended last summer in 'interests of students'

7 days ago
1

What you need to be doing to secure a training contract

John Watkins, Director of Employability at ULaw, talks AI in TC applications, adaptability, and excelling at virtual events

7 days ago
news SQE Hub

Students report difficulties getting QWE signed off

Lack of understanding among employers

7 days ago
16

Protest laws: Striking the balance between order and rights

Bar grad Abbas Hussain analyses the High Court's ruling on police powers in the Public Order Act 2023

Jun 5 2024 8:53am
4
news SQE Hub

SQE-you-later: Will the recent exam blunder deter future lawyers?

Law student Dara Antova gives her verdict on the Kaplan marking debacle

Jun 5 2024 8:52am
6